Skip to content
Gift Ideas6 min read
Wooden clips and twine in the StoryPop workshop in Bengaluru
Our real StoryPop workshop in Bengaluru. See our printing and packing process.

Scrapbook or Editorial Photo Magazine: Which Style Should You Gift?

By Amruth, StoryPop

StoryPop personalised photo magazines come in two styles for the same five occasions — love, birthday, best friends, sisters and her story. Both are 16-page A5 soft-cover magazines at the same price. What differs is the look, the amount of writing, and the kind of person they suit. This guide explains the scrapbook side in detail and how it compares, so you can pick in a minute.

Scrapbook vs editorial magazines at StoryPop
Scrapbook editionsEditorial editions
LookTorn paper, tape, florals, polaroid framesGlossy fashion-magazine layouts
WritingShort: about 5–6 answersLonger: interview-style answers and chapters
Dates usedNone neededSome editions use dates (e.g. together since, birthday)
PhotosLots per page, collage-heavyFewer, larger, styled photos
Time to makeAbout an eveningLonger, because of the writing
Format and priceA5, 16 pages, ₹499A5, 16 pages, ₹499

What is a scrapbook-style photo magazine?

It is a printed magazine designed to look like a hand-made scrapbook. Every page has a textured paper background, photos in white polaroid-style frames held down by printed washi tape, headings written on torn-paper strips, and small florals or stickers — a sunflower, a birthday cake, pressed daisies.

The five scrapbook editions are Love Scrapbook, Birthday Scrapbook, Best Friends Scrapbook, Sisters Scrapbook and Her Story Scrapbook. Each has its own colour palette and page designs: deep purple and rose for love, blush pink for birthdays, forest green and kraft for friends, deep maroon for sisters.

How is the editorial style different?

The editorial editions (AMOUR, BIRTHDAY, BESTIE, SISTERHOOD and MOMENT) look like a glossy magazine you would find at an airport bookshop, with the person you love styled as the cover star and features written about them.

Because of that, they ask for more writing — interview-style answers, chapter names for your story, timeline lines — and some use dates to build pages automatically. The scrapbook editions skip dates entirely and keep the questionnaire short: usually five or six answers, each with a "Use our suggestion" button.

Who suits the scrapbook style?

Choose a scrapbook edition if any of these sound right:

The person loves cosy, nostalgic, handmade things — journals, polaroids, dried flowers. You have a lot of photos and want most of them in the book. Scrapbook pages hold collages, including a heart made of a dozen small photos in the love edition. You are short on time or not confident writing. A few honest lines are enough. It is for a parent or grandparent, for whom a fashion-magazine look might feel odd.

Who suits the editorial style?

Choose editorial if the person would laugh with delight at being on a magazine cover, if you enjoy writing and want the gift to carry a lot of words, or if you have fewer but stronger photos. Editorial pages give each photo more room; scrapbook pages pack more in.

What is the same in both?

Both are A5 (148 × 210 mm), 16 pages, soft cover with a premium glossy, non-tearable paper, ₹499, printed in Bengaluru and shipped across India.

Both use the same editor. You upload 3 to 8 highlight photos for the cover and lead photos plus 20 to 40 others; phones can upload originals with zero compression. You answer the questionnaire, tap "Create my magazine", and then adjust each page with the whole A5 page on screen — joystick or drag to move a photo, zoom 1–3×, swap or remove, tap any text to edit it. The print file is rendered at 300 dpi from the exact page you approved.

Can I see both before deciding?

Yes. Every magazine's product page shows the cover and all seven open spreads, pages 2–3 to 14–15, plus the back cover. Open the scrapbook and editorial versions for the same occasion side by side; most people know within a few spreads which one feels like the person they are giving it to.

If you would describe the person as "cute", go scrapbook. If you would describe them as "iconic", go editorial. And if you cannot decide, the scrapbook is the safer gift for older relatives, the editorial for friends who love a bit of drama.

Which style for each occasion?

Love: the Love Scrapbook for cosy, photo-heavy couples; AMOUR for a couple who would enjoy a magazine-style love story with more writing.

Birthday: the Birthday Scrapbook for a warm, confetti-and-cake book with five short answers; the BIRTHDAY editorial edition when you want features about their year.

Best friends: the Best Friends Scrapbook for inside jokes and lots of photos; BESTIE for a glossy friendship feature.

Sisters: the Sisters Scrapbook for childhood photos and a few heartfelt lines; SISTERHOOD for a fuller story of growing up.

For her: the Her Story Scrapbook for a gentle tribute, often to a mother or grandmother; MOMENT for a cover-star portrait of her life.

Does the scrapbook style mean lower print quality?

No. Both styles are printed the same way from the same editor: the print file is rendered at 300 dpi from the page you see, using your original photos when you upload in original quality. The scrapbook look — torn paper, tape, textures — is part of the printed design, not a lower-quality finish.